Study Notes: Clone Beer
Beer Study Buddy commentary to help you study this category. The official BJCP guidelines remain the authority.
What this category is for
Commercial Specialty Beer, listed as Clone Beer in the 2015 guidelines, is the home for beers modeled on a specific commercial product that does not fit any existing style. The BJCP examples, Orval and La Chouffe, show the intent: both are well known, both are distinctive, and neither sits cleanly inside a defined Belgian style. A beer that clones a product that already fits a style, such as a well-known American IPA, should be entered in that style instead.
How judges approach it
The declared commercial beer becomes the reference point. Judges compare the entry to the character of that product: its malt and hop balance, yeast character, strength, carbonation, and finish. Because judges may not have tasted the original recently, the entrant's description matters, and a judge who does not know the reference beer should rely on that description and on general brewing quality. Faults are still faults; a clone of a beer with Brettanomyces should show the intended funk, not uncontrolled acidity or off-flavors.
Study tips
For the exam, remember the distinction between 34A and its neighbors. 34A requires a real commercial reference. 34B combines existing styles. 34C covers genuinely new concepts that are not clones and fit nowhere else. Be ready to explain why Orval belongs here: its dry, bitter pale ale base, high carbonation, and Brettanomyces character together do not match any single defined style.