Beer Study Buddy
← Back to syllabus topics

Advanced Cicerone® · Beer Flavor and Evaluation

Organic acids

Syllabus Path

Four organic acids are named in the Advanced Cicerone® syllabus: lactic (clean, yogurt-like sourness), acetic (vinegar), butyric (rancid butter, baby vomit), and isovaleric (cheesy, sweaty socks). Each points to a different organism or ingredient, so a candidate should identify the acid by aroma and taste, decide whether it is intended for the style, and trace it to a likely source.

  1. III. Beer Flavor and Evaluation
  2. C. Specific beer flavor compounds
  3. 3. Organic acids

Exam Focus

  • Identify acetic, butyric, isovaleric, and lactic acid by descriptor and connect each to its usual organism or ingredient source.
  • Compare lactic, acetic, butyric, and isovaleric acid impressions by sourness, aroma, sharpness, and contribution to balance.
  • Distinguish intended acidification or mixed fermentation from contamination and diagnose acidity alongside sweetness, alcohol, and carbonation.

The four acids

AcidDescriptorsUsual source
LacticClean, yogurt-like or lemony sourness, little aromaLactobacillus or Pediococcus
AceticVinegar, sharp, pungent aromaAcetobacter or Brettanomyces with oxygen
ButyricRancid butter, baby vomit, aged ParmesanClostridium and similar bacteria in poorly controlled wort or sugar
IsovalericCheesy, sweaty socksOld or badly stored hops; sometimes Brettanomyces

Intended acidity

Lactic acid is the backbone of Berliner Weisse, Gose, and many mixed-fermentation sours; it tastes sour but has little smell, which helps tell it from acetic acid. A modest acetic note is part of the profile of Flanders red ale and some lambics, where it adds sharpness to the fruit and oak. In these styles the question is balance: whether the acidity is clean, integrated with sweetness, alcohol, and carbonation, and appropriate in intensity.

Acids as faults

In a clean style, any noticeable acidity points to contamination or process failure. Acetic acid needs oxygen, so it suggests air exposure in fermentation, aging, or dispense, including dirty draft lines and spill trays where Acetobacter thrives. Butyric acid usually comes from bacteria growing in warm, poorly acidified wort, such as a kettle sour that was held too long or too warm, or contaminated sugar syrups; it is unpleasant at very low levels. Isovaleric acid usually traces to hops that have oxidized in storage, and it can also appear in some Brettanomyces beers.

Diagnosing acidity in context

Smell first, then taste. Vinegar aroma points to acetic; rancid or vomit-like aroma to butyric; cheesy or sweaty aroma to isovaleric; sourness on the palate with little aroma to lactic. Then check style intent and corroborating evidence: haze, overcarbonation, or film suggest ongoing microbial activity, while a cheesy note in a fresh, otherwise clean beer points to the hops. Acetic acid, isovaleric acid, and lactic acid are all on the Advanced Cicerone® off-flavor panel listed in the syllabus.

Why It Matters

  • Three of the four acids are on the Advanced Cicerone® off-flavor panel, so recognizing them is exam-relevant.
  • Each acid points to a different organism or ingredient, which directs the fix.
  • Telling intended acidity from contamination is essential for evaluating sour beers fairly.

Practical Sensory Exercises

Acid sorting

Compare a Berliner Weisse, a Flanders red ale, and a clean pale ale spiked with a drop of vinegar. Describe aroma and sourness separately for each, name the acid, and decide whether it is intended.

Key Terms

Lactic acid
Clean, yogurt-like sourness produced by Lactobacillus and Pediococcus.
Acetic acid
Vinegar-like acid produced from ethanol by Acetobacter in the presence of oxygen.
Butyric acid
A rancid-butter, baby-vomit acid from bacteria in poorly controlled wort or sugar.
Isovaleric acid
A cheesy, sweaty acid most often from oxidized, old hops.
Kettle souring
Souring wort with lactic bacteria before the boil; poor control can allow butyric acid.
Mixed fermentation
Fermentation by yeast plus bacteria or Brettanomyces, often producing intended acidity.

References

5 available