Beer Study Buddy
← Back to syllabus topics

Advanced Cicerone® · Beer Flavor and Evaluation

Advanced tasting exam exercises

Syllabus Path

The Advanced Cicerone® syllabus lists four tasting exercises: identifying off-flavors by comparing spiked samples with a control beer, giving five specific consumer-focused descriptors for an unknown sample, placing a sample as one of four beer styles, and writing a technical description of appearance, aroma, flavor, and mouthfeel. Each tests a different skill, from detecting a known compound to translating a full sensory analysis into precise language. Preparation means calibrated recognition of the listed off-flavors, deep style knowledge, and the habit of writing evidence before conclusions.

  1. III. Beer Flavor and Evaluation
  2. E. Tasting exam format
  3. 1. Advanced tasting exam exercises

Exam Focus

  • Describe the four tasting exercises in the Advanced Cicerone® syllabus and the skill each one tests.
  • Identify each of the twelve listed off-flavors by comparing a spiked sample with a control beer, and separate the four sulfur faults by descriptor.
  • Discriminate among four similar styles by tasting for the attributes that separate them rather than by a first guess.
  • Write a five-descriptor consumer description and a complete technical description, supporting every conclusion with sensory evidence rather than a style guess.

The four exercises

ExerciseWhat the syllabus describesSkill it tests
Off-flavor identificationDetect and identify off-flavors by taste, comparing spiked samples with a control beerCalibrated recognition against a known baseline
Consumer-focused descriptionOffer five specific, evocative descriptors for the key flavors of an unknown sampleChoosing the descriptors that matter most and expressing them clearly
Style discriminationCorrectly categorize a sample as one of four beer stylesSeparating close styles by their defining attributes
Technical-focused descriptionGive a complete descriptive analysis of appearance, aroma, flavor, and mouthfeel, using technical (chemical) terms when appropriateA full structured evaluation in precise vocabulary

The Cicerone® Certification Program publishes a sample Advanced Cicerone® tasting exam on cicerone.org; use it to see the format, and use the practice on this page to build the skills.

Off-flavor identification

Off-flavorMain descriptorsEasily confused with
AcetaldehydeGreen apple, fresh-cut pumpkin, latex paintFruity esters
Acetic acidVinegar, sharp sournessLactic acid, ethyl acetate
ChlorophenolMedicinal, adhesive bandage, plasticClove-like 4-vinylguaiacol, smoke
DiacetylButter, butterscotch, slick mouthfeelCaramel malt
DMSCooked corn, canned vegetablesCorn adjunct sweetness
H2SRotten eggMercaptan, young-lager sulfur
Isovaleric acidCheese, sweaty socksButyric acid, Brettanomyces funk
Lactic acidClean, yogurt-like sournessAcetic acid
LightstruckSkunkMercaptan, catty hops
MercaptanDrains, rotting vegetablesH2S, lightstruck
MetallicCoins, iron, bloodHarsh bitterness, astringency
Trans-2-nonenalPaper, wet cardboardMusty cork taint, general staleness

These are the twelve flavors the syllabus lists for this panel. Learn the control beer first, then use short sniffs and small sips on each sample and ask what it has that the control lacks. The four sulfur faults are the most crowded group, so separate them by descriptor: cooked corn for DMS, rotten egg for H2S, skunk for lightstruck, and drains or rotting vegetables for mercaptan.

Style discrimination

Here the task is to place one sample among four named styles. Before tasting, list the attributes that separate the four: color, bitterness level and quality, hop character by region, malt flavor on the color ladder, fermentation character (clean, fruity, phenolic, sour, or funky), body, carbonation, and strength. Then taste for those separators rather than for an overall impression. If the four were Munich Helles, German Pils, Kölsch, and Czech Premium Pale Lager, for example, the clues would be bitterness level and how it finishes, depth of malt, the character of the noble-type hops, faint fruit from Kölsch's ale yeast, and the low diacetyl the Czech style allows. Practice with commercial examples tasted blind in sets of four, rotating the sets so you learn the boundaries rather than a single beer.

Consumer and technical descriptions

The two description exercises draw on the same tasting skills but use different language. The consumer-focused description asks for five specific, evocative descriptors, so the skill is selection: the five words that best convey this beer's key flavors, ranked by prominence, specific enough to be useful (grapefruit pith rather than fruity, bread crust rather than malty), and free of jargon a guest would not follow. The technical-focused description must be complete: appearance (color, clarity, head), aroma, flavor, and mouthfeel, each with descriptors and intensity, plus chemical names where they apply, such as isoamyl acetate for banana or 4-vinylguaiacol for clove. In both, every descriptor must come from what you perceived. Writing a style's textbook profile for a beer that does not show it is an easy way to lose credibility.

Why It Matters

  • The syllabus names the four exercises and the twelve panel off-flavors, so practice can target exactly the skills the tasting exam measures.
  • Comparing each sample with a control trains you to detect a difference before naming it, which keeps identification honest.
  • Writing evidence before conclusions is what separates a credible technical description from a recited style profile.

Practical Sensory Exercises

Build a practice off-flavor panel

Using a commercial off-flavor kit, spike four or five of the listed compounds into a clean pale lager, keep one cup unspiked as the control, and have a partner code the cups. Identify each sample by comparison with the control, then repeat a week later with a different set of compounds.

Four-style blind set

Have a partner choose four styles of similar color and strength and pour one of them blind. Write the attributes that rule out the other three before naming it, then write five consumer descriptors and a full technical description of the same beer.

Key Terms

Control beer
The unspiked base beer that each spiked sample is compared against in off-flavor identification.
Spiked sample
A beer with a known flavor compound added at a set level to train or test recognition.
Off-flavor panel
The twelve flavors the syllabus lists for off-flavor identification, from acetaldehyde to trans-2-nonenal.
Style discrimination
Placing a sample as one of four named styles by tasting for the attributes that separate them.
Consumer-focused description
Five specific, evocative descriptors that convey a beer's key flavors in plain language.
Technical-focused description
A complete analysis of appearance, aroma, flavor, and mouthfeel that uses chemical terms where appropriate.
Descriptor
A specific word or phrase for a perceived quality, such as grapefruit pith or wet cardboard.

References

5 available