Beer Study Buddy
← Back to syllabus topics

BJCP Cider Judge Entrance Exam · Cider Judging Procedure and Scoresheets

Structured Cider and Perry Evaluation

Syllabus Path

A cider scoresheet should let the maker follow the sample from the first sniff through the last sensation after swallowing. Record fruit, fermentation character and appearance before judging how the cider tastes and feels. A perry can smell delicately floral, feel full on the tongue and finish with a drying grip. Each observation belongs on the sheet, and each helps explain whether the entry delivers its declared balance.

  1. 2. Cider Judging Procedure and Scoresheets
  2. B. Structured Cider and Perry Evaluation

Exam Focus

  • Evaluate fruit and fermentation aroma, appearance, flavor, mouthfeel, finish, balance, and overall impression in a repeatable sequence.
  • Distinguish sweetness, acidity, tannin, astringency, bitterness, alcohol, body, carbonation, and phenolics.
  • Revisit volatile, sulfur, oxidation, fruit, and structural character as the cider or perry warms and loses carbonation.

What the first pour reveals

Read the entered style and declarations. Smell the fresh pour while the bubbles are breaking. Name the fruit impression as precisely as the glass allows, then look for floral, estery, smoky or sulfury notes. Record their strength relative to the fruit. Look through the sample and describe hue, clarity, visible particles and the behavior of the bubbles. Slight haze can suit a perry. A blush can come from red-fleshed apples, so check any declared varieties before attributing the color to added fruit. Save the judgment about oxidation until aroma and flavor can corroborate the appearance.

Tracing a sip across the palate

Follow fruit flavor from entry to finish. Rate each sensation independently before deciding which one leads the balance. A cider can taste sweet at first and still leave the gums feeling dry.

SensationWhat to look for in the sip
Sweetness and acidityNote the sweet taste and the intensity of sourness. Does the acidity keep a sweet finish refreshing?
TanninRecord the drying grip on cheeks or gums under mouthfeel and any bitter taste under flavor. Tannin can also lend body.
Alcohol and bodyLocate warmth as you swallow and describe the weight on the tongue. Sorbitol can give perry fullness and some sweetness.
CarbonationDescribe the prickle from dissolved gas. A slight tickle can suit a declared still entry under the 2025 guidelines.
Phenolic characterName the flavor, such as smoke or clove, and whether it complements the fruit in this style.

Reading the finish twice

Set the glass aside briefly and return to it as the liquid warms and loses gas. Does the pear aroma become easier to recognize? Has an early sulfur note faded, or does it still obscure the fruit? Check for stale flavors as well as changes in acidity, grip and alcohol warmth. Follow the aftertaste long enough to notice a late mousy character. In the overall impression, connect a specific observation to style fit. For example, describe how lingering tannin gives an English Cider length even after the apple flavor recedes.

Why It Matters

  • Calling both acid and tannin 'sharp' hides whether the sample is sour, bitter, astringent, or some combination.
  • A second pass can reveal pear aroma, volatile acidity, mousiness, alcohol, or finish changes that were not evident on pouring.

Practical Sensory Exercises

Separate cider structure

Taste one cider and make independent intensity marks for sweetness, acidity, bitterness, astringency, alcohol warmth, body, and carbonation. Only after marking each axis, write a one-sentence balance conclusion.

Key Terms

Astringency
A tactile drying or gripping sensation, often felt on the gums and inner cheeks.
Body
The perceived weight and fullness of the liquid in the mouth.
Finish
The tastes, aromas and mouthfeel that persist as a sip ends.
Phenolic character
A family of sensory impressions that can include smoke, spice or leather.
Sorbitol
An unfermentable sugar alcohol in pears that can contribute sweetness and fullness to perry.

References

4 available