Beer Study Buddy
← Back to syllabus topics

BJCP Beer Judge Entrance Exam · Judging Procedure and Scoresheets

The 50-Point Beer Scoresheet

Syllabus Path

The BJCP beer scoresheet divides 50 points into Aroma (12), Appearance (3), Flavor (20), Mouthfeel (5), and Overall Impression (10). Around those sections sit identification fields, descriptor checkboxes, the style and technical grid, and the scoring guide bands. A candidate should know the allocations and fill the sheet so comments, section scores, total, and feedback all describe the same beer.

  1. 2. Judging Procedure and Scoresheets
  2. E. The 50-Point Beer Scoresheet

Exam Focus

  • Recall the five beer-scoresheet sections and their 12, 3, 20, 5, and 10 point allocations.
  • Make section comments, section scores, total score, and overall impression internally consistent.
  • Complete identification fields, style and technical grids, checkboxes, arithmetic, and legible feedback before submission.

The five scored sections

SectionPointsWhat it covers
Aroma12Malt, hops, esters, and other aromatics
Appearance3Color, clarity, and head (retention, color, texture)
Flavor20Malt, hops, fermentation character, balance, finish, and aftertaste
Mouthfeel5Body, carbonation, warmth, creaminess, and astringency
Overall Impression10Overall drinking pleasure and suggestions for improvement

Flavor and Aroma together carry 32 of the 50 points, which reflects how much they decide a beer's quality and style fit.

Score bands and the style grid

The scoring guide on the sheet ties totals to descriptions: Outstanding 45-50, Excellent 38-44, Very Good 30-37, Good 21-29, Fair 14-20, and Problematic 0-13. The style and technical grid rates Stylistic Accuracy, Technical Merit, and Intangibles on separate scales. Always fill in the grid, because it is a quick check against your numbers: a beer marked as a classic example with no flaws should not end up with a total in the Fair band.

A complete sheet

Write legibly and fill in the identification fields on every sheet: the entry number, the style the beer was entered as, and your name and judging information; many judges carry pre-printed labels with name, BJCP ID, rank, and email. Score every section. Writing only comments and a total, or only a few comments with all the scores filled in, is not acceptable. Comment on all relevant characteristics in each section, not just the most obvious one. Check the Stylistic Accuracy, Technical Merit, and Intangibles boxes, and mark a descriptor checkbox when that characteristic is perceived at a moderate or higher level or is a flaw in the style being judged. Note bottle condition so the entrant can follow up on handling questions. Check the addition before the sheet leaves the table; stewards double-check the math as well.

Internal consistency

The sheet must agree with itself. Section comments justify section scores, section scores add up to the total, the total falls in a band that matches the written description, and the Overall Impression agrees with the rest of the sheet. A sheet that praises a beer as clean and true to style but totals 24 sends the entrant a contradiction. When consensus changes a score, update the comments or section scores so the final sheet still tells one consistent story.

Why It Matters

  • Correct arithmetic cannot rescue a sheet whose comments describe a different quality level than its scores.
  • Complete paperwork gives entrants usable feedback and prevents avoidable competition administration problems.

Practical Sensory Exercises

Audit a 50-point sheet

Take a completed practice scoresheet and check five items in order: section evidence, point allocation, addition, score-band fit, and completion fields. Rewrite one comment or score that does not support the rest.

Key Terms

Overall Impression
The 10-point section summarizing drinking pleasure and improvement priorities.
Scoring guide
The bands that link totals to descriptions, from Problematic (0-13) to Outstanding (45-50).
Style grid
The scales for Stylistic Accuracy, Technical Merit, and Intangibles used as a check on the score.
Stylistic Accuracy
How closely the entry matches the style it was entered as.
Technical Merit
How free the entry is from flaws, regardless of style.
Intangibles
The overall life and appeal of the beer beyond accuracy and flaws.

References

6 available