Beer Study Buddy
← Back to syllabus topics

BJCP Beer Judge Entrance Exam · Judging Procedure and Scoresheets

Constructive Feedback Craft

Syllabus Path

The scoresheet is the judge's product, and entrants have paid to receive it. Feedback should be fair, polite, and encouraging, consistent with the score, and specific about how the beer could move closer to its style. Because the judge cannot see the recipe or process, possible causes are offered as possibilities rather than verdicts. A candidate should turn sensory evidence into prioritized, usable advice.

  1. 2. Judging Procedure and Scoresheets
  2. I. Constructive Feedback Craft

Exam Focus

  • Prioritize the sensory findings that most affect style fit or drinkability before offering changes.
  • Connect each suggested adjustment to an observed outcome and acknowledge successful elements of the entry.
  • Use conditional process language when the glass cannot distinguish among several recipe, fermentation, packaging, or handling causes.

What useful feedback includes

Feedback should explain how the brewer could adjust the recipe or process to produce a beer closer to style, and it should match both the characteristics the judge perceived and the score. It does not have to wait for the Overall Impression; saying in the Flavor section that the balance suits the style is feedback too. Calling out characteristics that are allowed in the style, such as low yeast character in an International Pale Lager, helps as well. Lead with the issues that cost the most points or most affect drinkability, and generally include at least one supportive comment about what the beer does well.

Diagnostic restraint

Comments should show knowledge of brewing, fermentation, bottling, and handling, but avoid excessive speculation about the recipe or process; a judge who guesses specifics will often be wrong. Make the suggestion conditional when several causes fit the same symptom: "If oxygen pickup is possible, review purging and transfers" is defensible, while "you splashed this during transfer" claims knowledge the judge does not have. Focus on sensory-based suggestions or changes in balance.

Tone and the bad-bottle possibility

Derogatory, snide, or rude comments are never acceptable. A bad entry may be one contaminated or inconsistent bottle, and in a multi-bottle competition the panel can ask for a second bottle to test that. A gusher or a beer with an unpleasant aroma still needs tasting and comments rather than a courtesy minimum score. Only if the judges genuinely believe a beer could be hazardous may they decline to taste it, explain why, give as much feedback as they can, and leave the scores blank, after first calling for a second bottle. Avoid filler comments that take space without adding information.

Worked rewrite

Weak: "Oxidized. Bad transfer technique. Fix your process." Better: "Moderate papery, wet-cardboard note in the aroma and flavor, with faded hop character; this pulls the beer away from the fresh hop profile the style needs. If oxygen pickup during transfer or packaging is possible, purging and closed transfers may help. The malt base is clean and well balanced." The rewrite gives evidence, explains the cost to style fit, suggests a conditional check, and acknowledges a strength.

Why It Matters

  • Unsupported certainty can send a brewer toward an expensive change that does not address the actual source.
  • Focused, encouraging advice is easier to act on than an unranked list of every possible fault correction.

Practical Sensory Exercises

Rewrite a diagnostic command

Start with 'You oxidized this beer during transfer.' Rewrite it as a sensory observation, two plausible source families, and one conditional packaging check that would help the entrant investigate.

Key Terms

Actionable feedback
A suggestion the entrant can reasonably act on to move the beer closer to style.
Diagnostic restraint
Offering possible causes conditionally instead of claiming to know the process.
Stylistic flaw
A departure from the entered style, as opposed to a technical fault.
Technical flaw
A fault such as an off-flavor that would be a problem in any style.
Second bottle
An additional bottle of the same entry requested to check whether a problem is isolated.

References

4 available