Beer Study Buddy
← Back to syllabus topics

BJCP Beer Judge Entrance Exam · Beer Ingredients and Brewing Processes

Turning Findings into Improvement Advice

Syllabus Path

Good judging advice names the one or two changes most likely to help, ties each to what was perceived, and says what should improve. The key first question is whether the beer has a fault or simply misses the style, since those lead to different suggestions. A candidate should write advice in proportion to the evidence and avoid assuming an unseen recipe, system, or process.

  1. 5. Beer Ingredients and Brewing Processes
  2. B. Turning Findings into Improvement Advice

Exam Focus

  • Choose the one or two changes most likely to improve the entry's largest sensory or style-fit limitation.
  • State the expected sensory result of each recommendation rather than issuing an unexplained process command.
  • Scale advice to the evidence and avoid assuming an undisclosed recipe, equipment configuration, or fermentation record.

Fault or style miss?

Sort the main issue before writing any advice. A clean, well-made beer that misses the style's balance is usually a recipe or target problem. An unexpected fault in a beer that otherwise fits usually calls for attention to process.

FindingTypeDirection of advice
Clean American IPA with too little bitternessStyle missAdjust hop or malt balance in the recipe
Festbier that tastes too caramel-sweetStyle missIf caramel malts were used, consider reducing them
Solventy alcohol in a Best BitterFaultReview fermentation temperature and yeast health
Papery note in a fresh-styled Pale AleFaultReview oxygen control and storage
Medicinal note in any clean styleFaultCheck water treatment and sanitizer rinsing

Prioritize

Lead with what costs the most points or most affects drinkability. A medicinal note matters more than slightly short head retention, and a long list hides the change most worth making. One or two focused suggestions, followed by minor refinements if there is room, give the brewer a clear next batch. Keep the advice in step with the score: a beer that scored 42 needs fine-tuning, and a beer that scored 22 needs its biggest problem named plainly. Generally include something the beer does well, so the brewer knows what to keep.

State the expected result

Tie each suggestion to the sensory change it should produce. "Fermenting a few degrees cooler may reduce the solventy alcohol in the finish" lets the entrant test whether it worked; "control your fermentation" does not. Say what to expect, not just what to do, and describe the change in the words used on the sheet so the two connect.

Scale advice to the evidence

Judges do not see the recipe, equipment, or fermentation records, so avoid advice that assumes them. Telling someone to lower their mash temperature assumes you know what it was. "If the mash was already low, the sweetness may come from caramel malts" allows for what you cannot see. Use conditional wording when several causes fit, and choose a general direction over a specific number when the evidence supports only that. Strong evidence earns firmer language: diacetyl alongside a clear fermentation pattern allows more confidence than one faint note.

Worked example

Observations on a Munich Dunkel: moderate toasty malt, very light roast harshness, slightly papery as it warms, good balance. A weak note says: "Use less roast, less crystal, better water, closed transfers, and more lagering." A better one says: "The malt character and balance are on target; keep them. The main issue is the papery note, which is taking away from the rich malt. If oxygen pickup is possible in transfer or packaging, reducing it should keep the malt fresher. If roast malts were used, a smaller amount would also soften the light harshness."

Why It Matters

  • A long correction list can obscure the change with the highest likely benefit.
  • Explaining the intended sensory result helps an entrant test whether a suggested adjustment actually worked.

Practical Sensory Exercises

Prioritize a correction plan

From a practice scoresheet with three weaknesses, rank them by effect on style fit and overall quality. Give one conditional action for the top issue and name the sensory change that would indicate improvement.

Key Terms

Style miss
A clean beer whose character or balance does not match the entered style.
Technical fault
An off-flavor or flaw that would be a problem regardless of style.
Recipe adjustment
A change to ingredients or targets that shifts a beer's intended balance.
Process control
A brewing practice that prevents faults and improves repeatability.
Expected outcome
The sensory change a recommendation is meant to produce.

References

4 available