Exam Focus
- Distinguish advancement-round comparison from rescoring a normal flight or carrying forward an earlier total.
- Evaluate entries independently before discussion, let other judges speak first about an entry you advanced, and do not argue from prior panels' scores or placements.
- Follow organizer procedure for ranking, ties, discussion, and final paperwork without using reputation or advocacy.
What advancement rounds do
When a category is judged in several flights, each panel sends its best entries forward, and a mini-BOS panel compares them to decide the category placings. Best of Show then compares category winners to pick the competition's overall winners. Both rounds are comparisons: the question is which beer is best on the table now, not what each scored earlier. Organizers set the procedure for ranking, ties, and paperwork, and the panel follows it.
Judge the beer on the table
Always pick the best entry on the table. Knowledge of earlier samples is not relevant, and bottles of the same entry can vary, so each round is judged without reference to what was learned in earlier rounds. A beer that scored 42 in its flight does not beat one that scored 38 if the second beer is better in this round. Each style should also have an equal chance of winning; judges should not deny a medal to a style because they consider it less important or less impressive.
Avoiding undue influence
A judge who passed an entry forward should avoid commenting on it until the other judges have had their say. It is fine to say, "I passed this one forward; I'd like to hear your opinion first." This keeps the judge from appearing to walk a favored entry through the round. Form your own impression before the discussion starts, describe the beers in terms of their strengths and limits against style, and do not argue from earlier scores or from guesses about who brewed an entry.
Saving beer for later rounds
During a flight, reserve some beer in each bottle and recap it when possible, because the top entries may need a re-taste or a mini-BOS. If you might need a repour, do not offer the leftover to stewards. Conserving beer should not come at the cost of fairness, though: asking for a second bottle to give a gusher or a possibly infected entry an accurate evaluation is better than saving a bottle for a round it has no chance of reaching.
Why It Matters
- Announcing an entry's earlier success can anchor the new panel before judges form their own impressions.
- Treating a prior numeric score as decisive ignores the comparative purpose and instructions of the advancement round.
Practical Sensory Exercises
Run a silent advancement pass
Taste three contrasting beers suitable for a mock advancement round. Rank them independently with one strength and one limitation each, then compare rankings without revealing any earlier practice scores.
Key Terms
- Mini-BOS
- A round that compares the top entries from several flights of a category to set the category placings.
- Best of Show (BOS)
- The final round that compares category winners to choose the competition's overall winners.
- Pass forward
- To advance an entry from a flight to the next round.
- Undue influence
- Advocacy, earlier scores, or other information that pushes judges away from independent judgment.
- Reserved sample
- Beer kept in a recapped bottle for a re-taste or advancement round.