Exam Focus
- Explain how entry anonymity limits reputation, identity, and expectation bias.
- Respond appropriately when packaging, conversation, or supplied information could identify an entrant.
- Recuse discreetly without announcing identifying details or inviting the panel to guess the source.
Why anonymity matters
Knowing or guessing who brewed an entry creates expectation bias. A judge who believes a beer comes from a respected brewer may hunt for its strengths, and one who suspects a rival may hunt for faults. Even a wrong guess spoken aloud can anchor the whole panel. Blind judging removes that information so every entry is measured against the same style guideline with the same scrutiny.
When an entry might be identifiable
If a label or other marking on a bottle could identify the brewer, look away and ask the steward to remove it, or ask the steward to pour the samples and take the bottle away. If you think you recognize a beer, say nothing about it and avoid guessing at the source. Let the other judges speak first before you join the discussion. The aim is to keep any knowledge you have from shaping the panel's evaluation.
Recusal without disclosure
Never judge a category you have entered. Entering and judging in the same competition is fine, as long as you do not judge your own category. If you are seated at such a flight, quietly find the judge director and ask to swap, without drawing attention to your entries in front of the judges who will score them. When another judge recuses, do not ask why; they are probably protecting blind judging or simply cannot continue. A judge who cannot perform because of illness, medication, an allergy to an ingredient in the flight, or alcohol should also step aside.
Anonymity beyond the table
Anonymity also covers what judges say in public. Do not post about what you will judge, ignore public information about what entrants have entered, and do not share identifiable details such as entry numbers or descriptions of beers you judged. If a panel needs to consult a judge from another table, ask first whether that judge has an entry in the category, because an entrant's opinion would be undue influence.
Why It Matters
- Speculating about a brewer can bias a panel even when the identification is wrong.
- A careful recusal protects both impartial scoring and confidential entry information.
Practical Sensory Exercises
Stop an anonymity leak
Write a two-sentence response for a panel where a judge recognizes a bottle: one sentence to stop identifying discussion and one private sentence to the head judge requesting the proper next step.
Key Terms
- Blind judging
- Evaluating entries without knowing who brewed them.
- Expectation bias
- The tendency to perceive what one expects, for example because of a brewer's reputation.
- Recusal
- Stepping away from judging an entry or flight because of a conflict or inability to judge fairly.
- Entry anonymity
- Protecting any information that could identify the entrant during and after judging.
- Undue influence
- Information or pressure that steers a judge away from an independent assessment.