Exam Focus
- Identify actual and apparent conflicts that require a judge to withdraw from an assignment.
- Apply confidentiality duties to entries, exam content, protected samples, and identifying information.
- Choose a discreet recusal path that alerts the proper official without influencing the remaining panel.
The principles
The Ethical Standards for BJCP Members, adopted in April 2021, rest on a few principles. All members have equal access to BJCP services. Members must avoid conflicts of interest and minimize the appearance of them, and must be impartial when judging or acting in an official role. Members may not directly profit from judging, administering or proctoring exams, or organizing competitions, where direct profit means payment beyond direct costs. Travel reimbursement offered by an organizer is acceptable, but it may not be demanded. Members may not use a BJCP position to restrict access to services or add fees, and may not use proxies to get around these rules.
Conflicts when judging
| Situation | Rule |
|---|---|
| An entry you made | Do not judge it |
| A category you entered | Do not judge that category, though you may judge elsewhere in the same competition |
| You work for or represent a brewery, including as a distributor, reseller, vendor, or agent | Do not judge entries from that brewery |
| You know the identity of an entry | Do not judge it |
The last rule covers actual and apparent conflicts alike. A promise to stay objective does not fix either one, because blind judging protects entrants' confidence in the result as well as the score. Working in the beer industry, writing, or teaching does not disqualify anyone, but it calls for extra care.
Stepping away discreetly
Raise a conflict early and privately with the judge director or organizer, who can reassign the entry or the judge. Say only that a conflict exists. Do not explain the connection to the panel, describe the entry, or invite guesses, because those details can bias the judges who remain. If you merely suspect a source with no real knowledge of it, say nothing about the suspicion and let the other judges speak first. A suspicion you cannot set aside is a reason to step away quietly.
Exams and confidentiality
No one may assist an examinee during any exam, including the online qualifier, except as approved under the Disability Policy, and no one may take an exam for someone else. Those with knowledge of an exam may not share anything about its questions or samples, including styles and faults, with examinees. Administrators may not perform multiple roles in one exam, require a class as a condition of taking it, guarantee seats to their own students, or sell seats. Violations can lead to a ban from a role or, in extreme cases, loss of membership, and a tainted exam or competition can have its results discarded.
Why It Matters
- Remaining on a panel with a known entry can compromise both the result and competitors' confidence even when the judge believes they can be objective.
- Oversharing during recusal can defeat blind judging and spread the very information the withdrawal was meant to contain.
Practical Sensory Exercises
Write a conflict response
For three situations (a beer you helped brew, packaging you recognize, and an entrant you merely suspect), write whether you would continue, pause, or recuse and exactly what you would tell the head judge.
Key Terms
- Conflict of interest
- A connection that compromises a member's impartiality; members must avoid these.
- Appearance of conflict
- A situation that could look compromised to others even if the judge is fair; members must minimize these.
- Direct profit
- Receiving money for services beyond direct costs; not allowed for judging, exams, or organizing competitions.
- Recusal
- Withdrawing from an entry or flight because impartiality cannot be assured.
- Equal access
- The principle that all members can use BJCP services without added conditions or fees.