Beer Study Buddy
← Back to syllabus topics

BJCP Beer Judge Entrance Exam · Judging Procedure and Scoresheets

Competition Judging Roles

Syllabus Path

A sanctioned competition splits authority among the organizer, judge director, head judge, judges, and stewards so entries move fairly from registration to results. Judges evaluate the beer in front of them; decisions about eligibility, disqualification, and category belong to competition officials. A candidate should know what each role may decide and route problems to the person who owns them.

  1. 2. Judging Procedure and Scoresheets
  2. A. Competition Judging Roles

Exam Focus

  • Differentiate the authority of the organizer, judge director, head judge, judge, and steward.
  • Route bottle, eligibility, category, and rules questions through the head judge to the responsible competition official.
  • Recognize actions judges and stewards must not take, including unilateral disqualification, reclassification, or sensory influence.

Who does what

RoleMain responsibilityLimits
Competition organizerOverall responsibility: registration, supplies, staff, running the event, returning scoresheets and prizes, filing the organizer reportFinal authority on rules, eligibility, and category moves
Judge directorRecruits judges, assigns them to categories, handles judging issues; ideally puts at least one BJCP-ranked judge, able to serve as head judge, on every flightMay judge only without knowledge linking entries to entrants
Head judgeReviews the styles and scoring with the panel, leads consensus, tutors newer judges, checks scores and paperwork, turns in completed sheetsLeads the panel but does not overrule competition officials
JudgeAny person whose scores count; evaluates and scores entriesMay not disqualify or move entries
StewardBrings entries in the order the head judge sets, supplies materials, double-checks forms and mathDoes not open entries unless the head judge directs it; stays out of discussion until consensus

Most flights have two to four judges, with two or three considered optimal, and one steward when possible.

What judges may not decide

Judges may not disqualify an entry; a questionable entry is referred to the judge director or organizer. Judges may not move an entry to another category even when it looks mis-entered or swapped, because only the organizer can make that change. To be fair to the entrant, a judge may write what score the beer would likely have earned in the right category, while remembering that the assumption could be wrong. Judges also never see entry forms. If the pull sheet lacks a required detail, such as the base style of a specialty beer, the organizer checks the form and passes the information back.

Escalating through the right channel

Problems travel through the steward or head judge to the official who owns them. Missing entry data, a possible bottle mix-up, or an out-of-style beer go to the organizer or registrar through the steward before anyone marks the entry down. A steward's instructions usually come from the organizer, so a judge who disagrees raises it with the organizer or head steward rather than arguing with the steward. A panel that reaches a true impasse on a score asks the organizer for help. In each case the judge keeps evaluating while the person with authority makes the procedural call.

Worked example

A panel opens an entry declared as a Weissbier that tastes like a roasty stout. One judge wants to score it as a stout; another wants to give it the minimum and move on. Neither is correct. The head judge asks the steward to have the organizer check for a sorting error or a second bottle. If the organizer confirms it was entered as Weissbier, the panel scores it as a Weissbier, explains why it does not fit the style, and may note how it might have done as a stout.

Why It Matters

  • When a judge exceeds role authority, a sensory opinion can become an unauthorized eligibility or placement ruling.
  • Clear escalation keeps the panel evaluating while the organizer protects consistent competition procedure.

Practical Sensory Exercises

Route four competition problems

Assign each situation (damaged bottle, missing declaration, suspected conflict, and disputed final paperwork) to the first role that should act and the role with final authority.

Key Terms

Competition organizer
The person with overall responsibility and final authority for a competition.
Judge director
The official who recruits and assigns judges and handles judging issues.
Head judge
The panel lead who reviews styles, leads consensus, and checks the paperwork.
Steward
The volunteer who brings entries, supplies materials, and checks forms; does not open entries unless directed.
Pull sheet
The flight list of entries and the details judges need, such as special ingredients.
Flight
A group of entries judged by one panel.

References

4 available