Exam Focus
- Describe aroma, appearance, flavor, mouthfeel, finish, and overall balance with specific qualities and intensities.
- Identify which qualitative characters are required, permitted, excessive, or absent for the entered style.
- Keep preference separate from evidence when a valid style expression differs from the judge's favored balance.
BJCP Beer Judge Entrance Exam Notes
BJCP judging application
BJCP style evaluation is built on narrative sensory parameters. Record what the sample presents in each sensory dimension, compare those findings with the entered style's required and optional character, and explain the resulting fit. Avoid converting broad terms such as 'malty' or 'hoppy' into unsupported recipe conclusions.
Intensity plus quality
A useful qualitative note has two parts: how strong a character is and what it is like. The 2021 guidelines pair graded intensity words (very low, low, moderate, medium-high, high) with specific descriptors, and judges should write the same way. "Moderate grainy-sweet malt" describes Munich Helles; "malty" alone fits half the guideline. The same two-part habit applies in every scoresheet section.
| Scoresheet section | Qualitative parameters to describe |
|---|---|
| Aroma | Malt, hops, esters, phenols, other aromatics, and any faults |
| Appearance | Color, clarity, and head size, texture, and retention |
| Flavor | Malt, hops, bitterness, fermentation character, balance, finish, and aftertaste |
| Mouthfeel | Body, carbonation, warmth, creaminess, and astringency |
| Overall Impression | Overall drinking pleasure and the most important strengths and weaknesses |
When a character is absent, say so. "No diacetyl" or "no hop aroma" is a real observation that helps the entrant and the other judge.
Balance, finish, and clean fermentation
Balance is the relative emphasis among malt, hops, and other elements, and the guidelines often state it outright. American IPA is hop-forward with clean, supporting malt, while Best Bitter can be more malt-balanced as long as that does not override its bitter impression. The finish is what happens as you swallow (dry, sweet, bitter, or lingering), and the aftertaste is what remains afterward. "Clean fermentation" means no noticeable esters, phenols, sulfur, or diacetyl beyond what the style allows; it does not mean a beer without flavor. These qualitative parameters are often what separate beers whose numbers overlap. The 2021 Style Comparison for German Pils, for example, separates it from Czech Premium Pale Lager mostly in qualitative terms: lighter body and color, a drier and crisper finish, more lingering bitterness, and higher carbonation.
Why It Matters
- Qualitative precision is what allows the written comments to justify a style-fit decision.
- Separating required from merely permitted character prevents judges from demanding every descriptor listed in a guideline.
Practical Sensory Exercises
Mark required, permitted, and excessive
For one entered style, choose six guideline descriptors and classify each as defining, optional, or limiting in context. Taste a representative beer and write evidence for presence, absence, or excess without scoring personal preference.
Key Terms
- Perceived bitterness
- Strength of bitterness a taster actually senses, raised or masked by sweetness, roast, warmth, and CO2.
- Finish
- Sensations remaining after swallowing, described by dryness, sweetness, and length.
- Intensity
- How strong a perceived character is, written with graded words such as low, moderate, or high.
- Balance
- The relative emphasis among malt, hops, fermentation character, and other elements in the overall impression.
- Aftertaste
- The flavor and sensation that remain after swallowing, including how long bitterness lingers.
- Clean fermentation
- No noticeable yeast-derived esters, phenols, sulfur, or diacetyl beyond what the style permits.